Skip to main content

Week 8 Comments and Feedback

I have received a lot of good feedback on my writing this semester! Honestly, I think that sometimes, the shorter comments tend to be more useful. Some of the longer comments just have filler to make the comment long enough to count. Other than that, I have really received good feedback for my writing, and I think I've been able to improve a lot. I think the biggest thing I've gotten is to use more dialog between characters. I didn't have a lot in my early stories, but I think the dialog in my later stories has really improved.

I've tried to give everyone I comment on good and helpful feedback. I've tried to find positive things to try to have people extrapolate from and build on to improve their writing, rather than simply just say something is bad. From giving others feedback, I think I've gotten ideas for how to change my own writing style.

I feel like I've gotten to know some of the people in the class a little better, although there are several other students that I knew previously. I actually learned a few things about them through their introductions, even a person I've known for almost 10 years. I think the introductions and comments on them were a really good part of the class, and did a great job of making the class feel more personal.

Going forward, I want to try to continue being as helpful and constructive as possible with my comments! It's no use commenting on people's posts only being negative the whole time, I want to have all of my comments be positive, even if I'm telling people ways to change their writing. I like the way my blog is going, and I don't really think I'm going to make any large changes.

Discomfort (Source: blogspot)
Just like looking in the mirror in the morning, feedback can be very discomforting. I think an important part of feedback is framing in a way that isn't confrontational or aggressive, but rather sincere and constructive. 

Comments

  1. Hey Callum. You are absolutely right about your dialogue. In your later stories, it had gotten to be really good. It isn’t blocky or fake sounding, rather, it reads more like how a conversation would sound. Your view on feedback is really similar to my own. No one will use feedback if it is given in a way that can be misconstrued as condescending.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Comment Wall

The Ruins of the Old World (Source:  pixabay ) Race for the Prize

Introduction to a Mechanical Engineering Major

My name is Callum Maguire, and I am a senior majoring in Mechanical Engineering. The coolest class I took last semester was AC Systems, which explored how air conditioning systems work and how they cool down rooms. Get it? Coolest class? Jokes aside, it was a very interesting course that opened my eyes to how complex a system the air conditioning in a building is, as even a single room can be a lot to deal with as far as calculations go. I was raised on Star Wars and Tolkien, so they happen to be some of my favorite works, however I'm also very fond of superhero movies, sitcoms like Community and IT Crowd, as well as sci-fi and fantasy novels. Long story short, I'm a nerd. Best movie I've seen recently is The Last Jedi, which is something of a controversial opinion I guess, but I don't care. I enjoyed it, and that's all there is to it. I recently re-read one of my childhood favorite novels, Redwall, which was a nice trip down memory lane. It was clear that it wasn

Week 7 Story: Demon Days

Long ago, in the land of Midor, there lived a humble man by the name of Shakiro. He was a simple man, and he led a simple life. One day, when Shakiro was wandering about the forest, searching for food, he encountered a a creature that had become trapped by some kind of strange apparatus. When he approached the odd creature, he was surprised to hear the creature speak to him! "Hello there, human. I was trapped here, unable to escape my bindings without assistance from a human... I don't imagine you'd be willing to help, so just run away now like the rest of your kind." This perplexed Shakiro, as he couldn't figure out why the creature would just assume he wouldn't help out. If Shakiro was anything, he was generous! He looked the creature up and down and decided he seemed harmless enough. "I will not run away!" Exclaimed Shakiro, "I'm going to free you, my friend." He took care to break the chains that held the creatu